discussion about Web 2.0 and associated issues the other day: bopuc/weblog: It’s not about you. Check it out, both his excellent post and the comments.
Boris wrote about a conference
he went to the other day and had an interesting experience: Documenting human rights abuses. I tried to write a comment on his site, but somehow his comment script kept rejecting it. So here is my comment:
Information wants to be free… when there isn’t a warlord at the other end of it who will use clear evidence of Western tampering and favouritism (clearly anyone featured in a North American website is supported by the US) as cause to raze the village and stop relief efforts by international organizations.
Information wants to be free… until that warlord repurposes the images to demonstrate how clearly those people need his help and protection and uses them to gain financial support from other organizations in his bid to be seen as the legitimate protector of villages he controls.
Boris I love the idea of the project and think it would be a great thing for you to bring to life. But the concerns they mentioned in the conference are pretty valid. People in parts of the world where basic human rights – food, shelter, right to life – are routinely abused have a lot to fear from such projects, and to do it right I think a group would have to go the extra mile to make sure those problems were addressed, and aggressively so.
I think Karl has hit on part of the solution, but if you are going to move forward with this – which I hope you understand I would thoroughly encourage you to do – I would recommend including a specialist in such development issues on the team. There’s a lot of bad history with abusive media representations of disadvantaged people, and I know you’d want to avoid that as far as possible.
Boris suggests
that people promote awareness of Creative Commons licensing options in Flickr. I agree with him in principle – but there’s a problem. As far as I can tell, a US CC license on Canadian-origin content is probably invalid, in particular since there are CC Canada licenses available. Should Flickr (and Six Apart and others) not provide international customers with an equal opportunity to add such a license?
Update: Anil Dash commented that Six Apart has added such support to Movable Type 3.2.
May I ask you
all for a small favour? Boris asked regular readers to unveil themselves and be known. Can you do the same here? I don’t keep track myself either, at least not very well, so it would be great if you could leave a comment and say hi with your name.
Boris
has published a fun piece on the relationship btw online and offline relationships, weblogs, tech-support forums, and the full circle between these among technologically engaged people in mid-decade: An example of information hunting and establishing connections between bits of data online.
